William Katz  /  Urgent Agenda


HOME


ABOUT


ARCHIVE


SNIPPETS


AUDIO


AUDIO ARCHIVE      


CURRENT QUESTION


CONTACT



 

 

SIZZLING SITES

Power Line
Faster Please (Michael Ledeen)
OpinionJournal.com
Hudson New York

Bookworm Room
Bill Bennett
Red State
Pajamas Media
Michelle Malkin
Weekly Standard  
Real Clear Politics
The Corner

City Journal
Gateway Pundit
American Thinker
Legal Insurrection

 


"The left needs two things to survive. It needs mediocrity, and it needs dependence. It nurtures mediocrity in the public schools and the universities. It nurtures dependence through its empire of government programs. A nation that embraces mediocrity and dependence betrays itself, and can only fade away, wondering all the time what might have been."
     - Urgent Agenda

I have a new piece up at Power Line this morning, called "Tina Fey:  Kingmaker."  It's here.

Daily Snippets are here.

We have a new audio clip, "What Our Side Must Do" (3:35).  You can listen here:



 

 

MONDAY,  DECEMBER 1,  2008


DRIVING READERS CRAZY - AT 11:16 P.M. ET:  The Detroit News online ran this headline today:  Ford puts Volvo unit up for sale.

But the story reads this way:   "Ford Motor Co. said this morning the economic decline and tight credit markets have forced it to consider the sale of its Volvo Cars unit.  Ford said the possible sale of Volvo is part of its "strategic review" to try and strengthen its balance sheet. Last year Ford sought buyers for Volvo, but later said the company wasn't for sale."

COMMENT:  In other words, they're considering selling the Volvo unit, but have not put it up for sale.  That's Journalism 101.


GREAT ANTI-TERROR IDEA, FROM MUSLIMS - AT 8:55 P.M. ET: 
From Fox News:  The Muslim Council of India is telling the nation's cemeteries that the bodies of gunmen killed by commandos in the Mumbai terror siege should not be buried on Indian soil, The Times of India reported Monday.  The religious organization told The Times that they were acting on complaints from several Muslim groups demanding that the bodies not be laid to rest in any Indian cemetery.

COMMENT:  This vigorous statement against terrorism, by Muslims, should be widely publicized.  Let's see if anyone but Fox pays any attention.



MUMBAI - THE REALITY


Posted at 8:26 P.M. ET:

How should we interpret the attacks in Mumbai?  Arthur Herman, a distinguished military historian, writes in National Review Online that the standard interpretations are probably wrong.  He gives his analysis, which seems sound because it reflects historical experience:

It’s been fascinating, but also disheartening, to watch the mainstream media completely miss the real story about the 60-hour terrorist rampage in Mumbai, India — which may have killed as many as 300 people, and has certainly injured hundreds more. What died in Mumbai — besides scores of innocent people in their hotel rooms and at the Mumbai Jewish Cultural Center and on the blood-drenched platform at Chatrapathi Sivaji railway terminal — were certain illusions about the war on terror, and how to deal with terrorists.

And...

Many put the blame for the attack on years of Indian-Pakistani hostility and tension. In fact, relations between the two countries have never been warmer. This past month, Pakistan’s new president stunned and delighted Indians by publicly renouncing any first use of nuclear weapons. Violence in Kashmir, the principal bone of contention between India and Pakistan since 1947, is on the decline.

So why the attacks?

This is precisely what the terrorists don’t want, of course. It’s the fact that tensions over Kashmir are diminishing that prompted them to attack on the November 28 — just as al-Qaeda blew up Samarra’s Golden Mosque in Iraq back in 2006 in order to keep Shias and Sunnis hating and killing each other. The illusion that formal agreements between peoples and governments — whether between India and Pakistan or Israel and the Palestinian Authority — can somehow defuse the terrorist problem was the among the first casualties in Mumbai. Terrorists see it the other way around: the relaxation of tensions is a problem requiring bloodshed.

We saw that in the Israeli-Arab conflict in the 1990s.  As the possibility of a peace agreement drew closer, terrorism increased.

Islamic terrorists don’t want justice or respect for their beliefs, or restoration of some imaginary homeland. They want violence and death.

And, according to Herman, another illusion died in Mumbai:

...that democratic nations can somehow opt out of the war on terror. India has largely operated on that assumption since 2001, even though it is home to the second-largest Muslim population in the world after Indonesia, and wedged between two neighbors — Pakistan and Bangladesh — where Islamic terrorist groups operate in relative freedom...

...India’s record on counterterrorism is abysmal, almost deliberately so. The government in New Delhi steadfastly maintains a wall of separation between law-enforcement agencies like the one that used to separate the FBI and CIA before the Patriot Act, and keeps counterterrorist units underfunded and undermanned. It has repeatedly given way to the demands of Islamic radical groups and fundamentalist lobbyists in the name of “cultural sensitivity.” India was the first non-Islamic country to ban Salman Rushdie’s Satanic Verses back in 1988.

Did them a lot of good.

In short, the Indian government has waged the war on terror in much the same way that liberals and many Democrats have been urging the U.S. to carry it out. The result is that more than 4,000 Indians have died in attacks since 2004 — more than any other nation in the war on terror besides Iraq.

We haven't been given much of this information by our media.

One reason the Mumbai terrorists sought out Brits and Americans to kill is that they can’t get at them in their own countries. The latest report is that those “evil” U.S. intelligence agencies had actually intercepted threats about possible attacks on hotels in Mumbai, and passed them on to their Indian counterparts — who then failed to take action.

Britain and the United States have learned how to deal effectively with terrorism the hard way. Maybe this time Indians will, as well.

We hope so, but much will depend on the example set by the Obama White House.  If Obama is smart, practical and honest, he'll see the truth in what writers like Arthur Herman are saying.  If he settles back to the old liberal "narrative," he'll give aid and comfort to those in India, and elsewhere, who believe appeasement and indifference are the preferred strategies, and we'll hear more illusionary talk about "root causes" than strategies for preventing the next attack.

December 1, 2008.      Permalink          

 


ELECTION TOMORROW, DON'T PANIC - AT 7:27 P.M. ET:  Georgia voters go to the polls tomorrow to settle the Senate race between incumbent Republican Saxby Chambliss and Democratic challenger Jim Martin.  This is a runoff, since no one got 50-percent in the November 5th voting.  Georgia and Minnesota are the two Senate races still left undecided.  The Dems need both to reach 60 votes in the Senate, a filibuster-proof number.  But last-minute polls have Republican Chambliss about five points ahead.


HE SPEAKS, HE LIVES - AT 7:21 A.M. ET:  From The Politico:   CHICAGO – Amid questions about his influence in the Obama transition and the potential for him to be overshadowed by Hillary Clinton as secretary of state, Vice President-elect Joe Biden spoke publicly on Monday for the first time since the election 26 days ago.  He stepped to the podium at the Chicago Hilton to congratulate Obama for bringing together “one of the most talented national security teams ever assembled.”

COMMENT:  I wonder how many Obama people had to clear that. 


WHOOPS, AT 4:47 P.M. ET:  A funny thing happened to the Dow on the way to an Obama rally.  It plunged 680 points today, to 8,150, wiping out half of last week's rally.  The National Bureau of Economic Research said today that the U.S. has been in a recession for a year. 


MUMBAI TERRORISTS AT LARGE? - AT 9:17 A.M. ET:  From The Times of London:   At least five terrorist gunmen have evaded capture in Mumbai and could make a secondary strike on India's financial capital, it was feared this morning.  Indian security forces are officially claiming that just ten militants – nine of whom were killed and one caught alive – were behind a co-ordinated terror attack that claimed nearly 200 lives.

However, the hijacked Indian fishing boat used by the gunmen to approach Mumbai, the crew of which were also slaughtered, had equipment for 15 men on board when it was discovered adrift off the city shore – suggesting that several gunmen could still be at large.


STILL IN THE TANK FOR OBAMA - AT 8:19 A.M. ET:  We just love these little word games that journalists play to do their bit for Barack.  Consider this New York Times headline today:  A Handpicked Obama Team for a Shift in Foreign Policy.

COMMENT:  Really?  Handpicked?  The term is used to make it look as if the selections were determined oh so carefully.  But has any president not handpicked his team?  Has it ever been done any other way?  By computer?  Lottery?  Phoning a friend?  If it had been George W. Bush the headline would have read:  Bush leans on Washington insiders.  You can bet on it. 


LIKE CLOCKWORK.   A FEW MINUTES AFTER WE PUBLISHED RENEE NIELSEN'S PICTURE, JUST BELOW, WE RECEIVED THIS DISPATCH FROM HER, IN MUMBAI:

It's been interesting reading in the papers and watching the news today.  It is just become accepted (whether true or not) that Pakistan is behind the attacks.  No agency is specifically saying the Pak gov't was direcly involved. However, allowing terrorist groups such as Lashkar-e-Tayyaba (LeT) to operate on its soil makes them accomplices.  Reports also talk about the US being concerned about escalation between the two nations, but Indians seem to be preoccupied with the internal blame game right now.

The Times of India reports that three RDX bombs were found around the Taj and Trident hotels.  One bomb was kept in a metal container inside a backpack with a timer. It doesn't appear that it was set because they report a nine-volt battery would have given it power.  

The political casualties have started:  Union Home Minister Shrivraj Patil has quit under pressure for lack of confidence and his inability to protect India from continuous terror attacks.  

Two others have gone as well, including Maharastra Chief Minister Vilasro Deshmukh.  This guy took his son (an actor) and, allegedly, a movie director named Ram Gopal Varma, who is known to make "thrillers or real life themes," according to the Hindustan Times, down to the Taj for a tour of the devistation.  I write allegedly only because Deshmukh says that Varma's presense was a coincidence and that he didn't arrange it.  It doesn't matter, as the media believes it, and people are outraged at these "VIP" tours, regardless of who went.   Ultimately, Deshmukh had to resign due to heavy opposition from all sides.  

Deputy Chief Minister RR Patil has also resigned.  He started a controversy by saying that the attacks were "a small incident."  Ouch.  

Different politicians are saying that it's not the politicians' fault the attacks happened, but was a failure of all agencies.  

There is a major election in January.  The finger pointing only took a few days to get started.

The Leopold Cafe re-opened for just 30 minutes because it was mobbed by media, customers and concerned police. The owner, Farzad Jehani, wanted to make a statement that he won't be intimidated by terrorism.  It looks as if 10 people died inside during the attacks.  

There are lots of reports coming out that fishermen, a few months ago, told authorities that RDX was coming into the ports, and that the authorities didn't act on the information.  There are more reports that the Indian Navy and Coast Guard also didn't act on intel tips, etc.  

As for my opinion:  This is a big, messy, chaotic country. The Indian police forces, military and their equipment, transport, and even their leadership are beyond inadequate. Even so, many did lay down their lives to stop the terrorists.  They're being treated as heroes now (martyrs) for India.  It's very sad watching the families mourn.  The Indian media has no problem putting a camera in their faces to see if they can score an interview.

We look forward to more from Renee.  She provides these little tidbits and insights that we're not getting elsewhere.



RENEE


Posted at 7:19 a.m. ET

A number of readers have remarked on the outstanding work done by Renee Nielsen during the tragic hours of the Mumbai siege.  Her dispatches added depth and insight to our reports. 

Renee is president of Republicans Abroad in India.  As you've seen, she's intelligent, lucid and highly perceptive.  Here's a picture of her taken at an Indian festival in September.  Now you can associate a face with the name.

Renee's father, by the way, is a retired Air Force pilot who flew F4 Phantoms during the Vietnam War.  He was retrained to fly F16s and became a member of the Minnesota Air National Guard, based in Duluth.  He retired from the Air Guard as vice commander of the 148th Fighter Group.   

We look forward to hearing more from Renee.

December 1, 2008.      Permalink          



KRISTOL ON JIHAD

Posted at 7:10 a.m. ET

It doesn't take long after an event like Mumbai for the usual suspects to make their way into the marketplace of bad ideas.  I wrote here earlier that the American journalism we saw during the awful siege was actually pretty good, in some cases excellent.  But now the "scholars" are weighing in, each one more profound than the next.  You know what to expect.  Bill Kristol provides the answers:

Consider first an op-ed article in Sunday’s Los Angeles Times by Martha Nussbaum, a well-known professor of law and ethics at the University of Chicago. The article was headlined “Terrorism in India has many faces.” But one face that Nussbaum fails to mention specifically is that of Lashkar-e-Taiba, the Islamic terror group originating in Pakistan that seems to have been centrally involved in the attack on Mumbai.

This is because Nussbaum’s main concern is not explaining or curbing Islamic terror. Rather, she writes that “if, as now seems likely, last week’s terrible events in Mumbai were the work of Islamic terrorists, that’s more bad news for India’s minority Muslim population.” She deplores past acts of Hindu terror against India’s Muslims. She worries about Muslim youths being rounded up on suspicion of terrorism with little or no evidence. And she notes that this is “an analogue to the current ugly phenomenon of racial profiling in the United States.”

So jihadists kill innocents in Mumbai — and Nussbaum ends up decrying racial profiling here. Is it just that liberal academics are required to include some alleged ugly American phenomenon in everything they write?

And...

Jim Leach is also a professor, at Princeton, but he’s better known as a former moderate Republican congressman from Iowa who supported Barack Obama this year. His contribution over the weekend was to point out on Politico.com that “the Mumbai catastrophe underscores the importance of vocabulary.” This wouldn’t have been my first thought.

No, mine neither.  But we don't teach in the Ivy League.

But Leach believes it’s very important that we consider the Mumbai attack not as an act of “war” but as an act of “barbarism.”

It's something, Leach says "that can occur anywhere, anytime..."

Just folks.  Just ordinary folks.  Oh, yes, Leach does concede that "it may be true" that the murderers saw themselves as justified in their attacks, that they may have had a rationale for killing people of different nationalities.  Kristol replies:

But Leach doesn’t want to discuss that rationale — even though it’s not hard to find. Ten minutes of Googling will bring you to a fine article, “The Ideologies of South Asian Jihadi Groups,” from the April 2005 issue of Current Trends in Islamist Ideology. It’s by the respected journalist and diplomat Husain Haqqani, who, as it happens, is now Pakistan’s ambassador to the United States.

Lashkar-e-Taiba, Haqqani explains, is a jihadi group of Wahhabi persuasion, “backed by Saudi money and protected by Pakistani intelligence services.” He notes that “Lashkar-e-Taiba has adopted a maximalist agenda for global jihad.” Indeed, the political arm of the group has conveniently published a pamphlet, “Why Are We Waging Jihad?,” that lays out all kinds of reasons why the United States, Israel and India are “existential enemies of Islam.”

And...

But if terror groups are to be defeated, it is national governments that will have to do so. In nations like India (and the United States), governments will have to call on the patriotism of citizens to fight the terrorists. In a nation like Pakistan, the government will have to be persuaded to deal with those in their midst who are complicit. This can happen if those nations’ citizens decide they don’t want their own country to be dishonored by allegiances with terror groups. Otherwise, other nations may have to act.

Kristol lays it out directly, and clearly.  His argument is in the real world not the academic world.  It will not get him dinner invitations in Cambridge or Princeton, but he is correct.  The last thing we need now is for the punditocracy and the academics to overintellectualize what has happened, and we fear that this is what might occur, just as it occurred in the universities after 9-11.  Former Congressman Leach has been captured by the academic mentality.  That mentality, as it is currently expressed, will not serve the nation well.

December 1, 2008.      Permalink          

 

 

 

SUNDAY,  NOVEMBER 30,  2008


NEWS NOTE AT 11:58 P.M. ET:  Some readers may have noticed that we've been a little light in posting this weekend.   It was intentional.  Holiday weekends are notoriously thin on news, barring something entirely unexpected.  Of course, we dealt in detail with Mumbai, and will continue to do so, but American news has been less than compelling.  The AP report has not been significantly updated in hours. 

The situation might change tomorrow morning with the naming of the president-elect's national-security team.  It will certainly change if Mumbai is followed by other like events, or by a convulsion on the Indian subcontinent.  Mr. Obama can expect an eventful first year.


THIS JUST IN - AT 4:27 P.M. ET:   (Bloomberg) -- French President Nicolas Sarkozy voodoo dolls can still be sold by a publisher as long as they come with a warning that sticking pins in the toy is an affront to his dignity, a Paris court ruled today.  The court rejected Sarkozy’s appeal to block the sale of the dolls. It awarded him 1 euro ($1.27) and required the warning labels be added to the packaging in conspicuous block lettering.

COMMENT:  I was thinking of a line of Hillary Clinton voodoo dolls.  I guess I'll need the label for the French version. 


THE BOTTOM LINE - AT 2:43 P.M. ET:  Nov. 29 (Bloomberg) -- U.S. holiday retail sales increased 3 percent yesterday from a year earlier, the smallest gain for a “Black Friday” in three years, research firm ShopperTrak RCT Corp. said.  Sales rose to $10.6 billion, the Chicago-based company said in a statement. The increase was the smallest since a decline of 0.9 percent in 2005 and compares with a jump of 8.3 percent last year.

COMMENT:  The key, of course, is how much profit is involved here.  With stores cutting prices dramatically, even an increase in sales may not tell the story.  However, don't despair.  The economy will, after Obama is inaugurated (check one) 1) start to race again on a burst of optimism; 2) forge ahead with confidence in the new team; 3) show signs of life as Americans look to a new day.

None of this will be true, but that's what we'll be told.  The media got plenty of practice during the campaign.


THE CLINTON WATCH BEGINS...AGAIN - AT 10:06 A.M. ET:  WASHINGTON (CNN) -- President-elect Barack Obama is planning to nominate at least three key members of his national security team at an event in Chicago, Illinois, on Monday, including Sen. Hillary Clinton as secretary of state, according to two Democratic officials.

COMMENT:  Without doubt, Clinton is the most fascinating cabinet pick since Nixon chose Henry Kissinger for State.  Bets are starting on how long Clinton will last.  What happens if she's ordered to take positions vastly different from her beliefs - or at least the beliefs she claimed when she was senator from New York?  What if there's a feud at the political summit between Clinton and Obama?  Oh, the juiciness of it all.


THE IRAN GAME


Posted at 9:54 a.m. ET

The Mumbai attack inevitably makes us think of other sources of terror, and worse than terror, around the world.  The name Iran comes up.  The mad mullahs haven't been too prominent in the news recently, but that will certainly change once Mr. Obama takes office and the issue of Iran's nuclear program comes front and center again.

But there is something else that gets our attention regarding Iran, and that is its disturbing relationship with Germany.  When Germany was reunified after the end of the Cold War - or at least the pause in the Cold War - some wondered out loud whether reunification was a good idea.  Would Germany become Germany again, returning to its bad old ways?  The answer, sadly, is that it increasingly looks that way.  No, there isn't a Hitler on the horizon, and the German army isn't massing on the French border.  But Germany has become increasingly anti-American and indifferent to Western causes.  The Wall Street Journal reports on its disturbingly close relationship with Iran, and the amorality behind it:

The recent U.N. report that Iran may have enough nuclear material to build an atomic bomb is causing concern in Germany -- not over an Islamic bomb, but over the risk of tougher U.N. sanctions.

As we said, amorality.

The German-Iranian Chamber of Commerce sponsored a seminar this week in Hamburg entitled "Iran Sanctions -- Practical Consequences for German Companies." The session was designed to help firms in "these difficult times" -- a reference to U.N. trade sanctions, not the global economy.

Our great ally.  Are you glad we rebuilt them after World War II?

As Europe's largest exporter to Iran, Germany has unique leverage over the regime. But Berlin refuses to use it. German exports to Iran are up 14.1% in the first seven months of this year. The Islamic Republic is so popular in Germany that another group, Management Circle, is planning a two-day crash course next month in Frankfurt. The program lists seven reasons for doing business with Iran, including "traditional good economic and political relations with Germany."

There was a time when German governments would feel an obligation to distance themselves from regimes that were anti-American or anti-Semitic.  Apparently, that is no longer the case, even though German Chancellor Angela Merkel is herself pro-American.

Readers may recall that Barack Obama assailed President Bush for not doing more diplomatically to contain Iran, including more vigorous sanctions. Job one on that score for Mr. Obama would seem to be persuading his many admirers in Germany. Good luck.

The question is whether Obama is willing to risk unpopularity in Germany to get our point across.  German relations with Iran, which apparently include the sale of scientific and technical equipment, are only expected to grow.

This situation has been deteriorating for some time.  There are German troops "assisting" us in Afghanistan, but they're not allowed to fight, and even their commander said this past week that their mission is a failure.

It may be time for the American people to vote with their dollars and bypass those German products until the Fatherland comes around and recognizes that it must contribute substantively to Western defense, not just take.

November 30, 2008.      Permalink          



MUMBAI UPDATE AT 8:48 A.M. ET:  Most of the "news" out of Mumbai this morning is actually speculation.  Apparently, only one of the ten attackers survived.  He is being questioned by Indian police and is said to be "talking."  Of course, we don't know if he's saying anything accurate.

The key question to emerge is whether Pakistan or Pakistanis are directly involved.  There have been Indian government statements claiming Pakistani involvement, but no smoking gun has thus far been produced.  Proof of Pakistani complicity, whether by the government or individual groups, could touch off armed clashes between India and Pakistan, something Washington doesn't need right now, as U.S. forces try to calm the border between Pakistan and Afghanistan.

A final casualty toll has not been announced.  Newspapers vary in their report on the death count thus far, ranging from about 180 to about 195.  But authorities have cautioned that more bodies might be discovered inside the Taj hotel. 

 

 


 

 

 

"What you see is news.  What you know is background.  What you feel is opinion."
    - Lester Markel, late Sunday editor
      of The New York Times.

 

SUBSCRIBER CORNER

The new edition of Subscriber Services, sent Wednesday, covers:

1.  Trends of the week, our standard feature.
2.  The third Pompous Fool Award, given with warmth to a retiring politician.
3.  Truth in Journalism - Another journalist concedes major media bias.
4.  Not Funny in Minnesota - The dark side of comedians, even those who might be senators.
5.  An audio remembrance of November 22, 1963.

 


SUBSCRIPTIONS

Subscriptions to URGENT AGENDA are voluntary.  Why subscribe to something you're getting free?  To help guarantee that you'll continue to get it at all, and to get the additional features we now offer subscribers. 

Subscriptions sustain us.  Payments are through PayPal and are secure, but you do not have to sign up for a PayPal account.  Credit cards are fine.


FOR A ONE-YEAR ($48) SUBSCRIPTION, CLICK:

FOR A SIX-MONTH ($26) SUBSCRIPTION, CLICK:

IF YOU DON'T WISH A SET SUBSCRIPTION, BUT PREFER TO DONATE ANY OTHER AMOUNT TO SUSTAIN URGENT AGENDA, CLICK:

 

THE CURRENT QUESTION

This space will regularly raise questions that relate to the news, but transcend daily headlines.  The idea is to stimulate talk about basic issues. Our last question asked: 

Last week we asked:

Give us a brief picture of America after four years of an Obama administration.

You can view the answers here.

 

NEW CURRENT QUESTION

Why do you think Mr. Obama has chosen a relatively centrist national-security team, rather than a decidedly liberal team?


If you'd like to send us your thoughts, click:
response@urgentagenda.com
(Please stay within two or three paragraphs.  We try to print every reply, if space allows.  Place your name at the end of the message if you wish your name published.  This question will stay up through Sunday.)



SEARCH URGENT AGENDA

Search For:
Match: 
Dated:
  From: ,
 To: ,
Within: 
Show:   results   summaries
Sort by: 

 

POWER LINE

It's a privilege for me to post periodic pieces at Power Line. To go to Power Line, click here.

To link to my Power Line pieces, go here.

 

CONTACT

YOU CAN E-MAIL US, AS FOLLOWS:

If you have wonderful things to say about this site, if it makes you a better person, please click:
applause@urgentagenda.com

If you have a general comment on anything you see here, or on anything else that's topical, please click:
comments@urgentagenda.com

If you must say something obnoxious, something that will embarrass you and disgrace your loving family, click:
despicable@urgentagenda.com

If you require subscription service, please click:
service@urgentagenda.com

 

 


 



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

     
     
     
     
````` ````````